Sunday, November 29, 2009

DNF 2009

Here is my list of the books I could not, would not, or refused to finish in 2009. There is still December to think of but as I am on a Miss Read kick combined with other Christmas reads, I seriously do not think I will run into any more books I won't be able to finish this year.

1. Why We Hate by Dick Meyer - On an every day basis I have to deal with people who irk...those who think everybody else wants to listen to their music; people who don't even know there is such a thing as cell phone etiquette; people who have forgotten to use words like hello, good-bye, thank you, you're welcome, have a nice day, excuse me; and so on and so forth because Lord knows I could go on forever. Since I have to live it, I choose not to immerse myself in a book about it...too frustrating (especially if I do not agree with the author on some of the causes and the cures). (p.22) I wrote this DNF note at the beginning of the year and have since moved to a town where I haven't encountered these same frustrations but I still won't be reading this one...too negative.

2. Lolita by Vladimir Nabakov - Just can't do it and believe me I tried...65 pages of trying but here is the thing, I have a thirteen year old daughter and I can't turn off that mother part of me when reading a book...just can't. I chose Lolita for one of my mini-challenges where you are asked to read a book outside of your comfort zone and this has always been that book for me...and I guess it will continue to be so. (p. 65)

3. Thirteen by Lauren Myracle - My daughter began this series with Eleven and it has become a tradition for me to buy the latest installment on her corresponding birthday. She loved Eleven and Twelve but had a hard time finishing Thirteen. I decided to give Thirteen a try for my YA challenge but couldn't get into the story. Maybe I should have started at the beginning but I can tell when a book/author just isn't the right fit. (Chapter 2)

4. Writing Home by Alan Bennett - This book is a good read but at 600+ pages it is too much Bennett all at once. I will return and finish this at some point.

5. Mennonite in a Little Black Dress by Rhoda Janzen - Janzen is very funny and there was one part in this memoir where she describes what it was like to go on camping trip with her family that I was laughing so hard I had to put the book down. But I couldn't get past the feeling that under the layer of humor she was jabbing members of her family and the community she had grown up in in a mean-spirited way. There were also two too many incidences of TMI which as my age progresses my tolerance for decreases. (p. 61)

Going over this list has got me thinking about the books I did finish but couldn't stand. On some occasions I finished because I was reading for a challenge. On others, my curiosity to see how the book ended sustained me through my disdain. But the first question asked when I say I didn't like a book is 'why did you keep reading' and, looking back, whatever the reason it wasn't good enough to justify the time and the frustration. I should have moved on and, if I have any reading resolutions for 2010, to move on will be at the top of my list.

15 comments:

JoAnn said...

Writing Home sounds like a case of Bennett overdose! Smaller doses may be just the thing. Lolita was a book group selection about 5 years ago, and the mother in me had great difficulty finishing it. For a while, I doubted I'd be able to. I just saw Mennonite in A Little Black Dress the other day, and was wondering about it. Guess I won't add it to my list right away. Interesting post!

Jenny said...

It's a shame you couldn't get through Lolita, but no surprise - my mother has the exact same reaction every time she tries to read it. I'm glad I read it in college, myself; it's a wonderful book and I expect when I have kids I'll have a harder time with it.

dolcebellezza said...

I completely understand not being able to finish Lolita. I have a thirteen year old neice, and about twelve girls in my class who will soon be thirteen, and it's just so close to home. I did read it, because I had to know what all the fuss was about, and because (in general) I love Russian literature. But, I can't say I'm better off for having read it. If anything, it only confirms the way we have to guard our children with our lives. He was such a twisted man...

Diane said...

I like what you said about moving on and not reading a bad book in 2010. Too much out there to read to bother completing bad or mediocre books.

Thomas at My Porch said...

Although I think Lolita is a great book, I can understand having a 13-year old daughter might shade your reading of it at the moment.

readerbuzz said...

I like this list. Mine would be very long. I agree with you about several books...just don't think I'll ever read Lolita. Makes me cringe.

Sharon said...

I usually finish a book that has lost my interest thinking surely it will get better. Besides if I bought it I hate to throw my money away. If it is a library book, I don't mind just taking it right back without finishing it.

Book Psmith said...

Jenny - I do wonder what my reaction would have been if I had picked it up earlier. I don't think I will give Lolita another try but do want to try another one of his books.

Thomas at My Porch - It is fascinating the way where we are in life can affect how we read a book and how we choose the books we read. Not the first and not the last casualty:)

readerbuzz - I have a feeling the list will be longer next year:) The idea of it made me cringe and I think I should have trusted that reaction.

Diane - Amen:) And as my tbr list and wishlists continue to grow, I know you couldn't be more right about not bothering with the bad reads.

JoAnn - I bet that was an interesting group meeting:) Just from reading other posts around the blogosphere on Lolita, it seems to generate a lot of conversation.

dolcebellezza - I always think of mother and protector as being interchangeable. I am with you on Russian literature as well as a huge chunk of Russian classical music:)

Darlene said...

There are just way too many books to read that excite us to spend time reading one that doesn't. You are to be admired for the way you challenge yourself though!

Beth F said...

I gave up forcing myself to finish every book I started many years ago. There are just way too many good ones out there. I love Lolita, but I can understand why you couldn't finish it.

Book Psmith said...

Beth F - You and Nan got me to really assess why I was pushing through to the end of books I didn't like...thank you:)

Darlene - I think my tbr list will be the biggest motivator to move on...a reminder of all those exciting books out there just waiting to be read:)

Sharon - I share that hope as well that the book will get better but looking back, it is truly the rare book where that happens. I hate the thought of wasting a book as well...donating helps me deal with the guilt and also utilizing the library if it is a book I am not too sure about. Thank goodness for libraries:)

Nan said...

Geez Louise, I was just about to leave a comment when I saw my name! I am the queen of quitting. There are sososo many books out there, and I am pushing 62 really really hard, so I have no prob-bob letting a book go that I am not enjoying.
I wouldn't even open Lolita. Yuck. I've not kept track of my DNF books.

Book Psmith said...

Nan - Yup...you get a thank you too for getting me to rethink my need to finish especially when I look back and see that one book I couldn't stand this year and know that I would have been better off in so many ways if I had listened to that little voice that was saying 'why are you still reading this'.

Lisa said...

It's funny that you said that "Mennonite" has too much TMI that at your age you don't have a tolerance for because my 76-yr-old mom highly recommended this book to me. Maybe she's so old she didn't get it!

Book Psmith said...

Lisa - LOL...more than likely it has to do with my tendency towards prudishness:)