Two years ago, I chose Oliver Twist as my initiation into the world of Dickens. I loved it then and I am loving it more the second time around because there is a distance now between me and the movie musical which so colored my first reading. I am pretty sure this distance is due to getting to know Dickens through a few of his other works. I am grateful for it; I did not want to spend this reading of OT singing 'consider yourself at home' and 'oom-pa-pa, oom-pa-pa, that's how it goes', nor experiencing the characters at the same superficial level portrayed on-screen. I do admit to singing 'consider yourself at home' but after my reading and not during...that, my friends, is progress...and the characters are so much more alive to me. I am seeing Nancy in a whole new light, just as tortured and torn as Oliver, and some characters I feel as if I am truly seeing for the first time, like Mr. Brownlow, Mrs. Bedwin and Mr. Grimwig (what a fantastic name!).
So, this is Dickens at 25, and I feel that youth in his writing, in his narrating which feels so intimate when he addresses the reader directly. He writes about this stuff that would be downright depressing on its own except he keeps it light with sarcasm and humor, and keeps it hopeful with small gestures of kindness exhibited by his characters.
He has to because he places you on this roller coaster right from the start: the death of his mother to the small kindness extended by Mrs. Thingummy, the lows of living with Mrs. Mann to the little windows of goodness displayed by Mr. Sowerberry, and currently in the throes hoping Oliver can escape the evil of Fagin and Sikes and find his way back to Mr. Brownlow. One thing that remains the same between my two readings is the suspense; I am still anxious to know what will come next.
During my reading of Little Dorrit, I pretty much loved any part that skewered bureaucracy and politics as seen through the prism of the circumlocution office. I didn't notice this so much during my first reading of OT but am definitely appreciating the chance to see it right off in the second chapter regarding "Oliver's growth, education and board". Dickens is so, so good at this. I need to start a list, Dickens on Society, so I can go back and read these passages when in need of some levity looking at today's world.
This is my first time participating in a read-along and I can't wait to share the experience with other readers. But you don't have to be a part of the read-along to share your thoughts if you have read OT in the past. Thank you to Allie for hosting this event.
11 comments:
Oh, I'm glad to see you're reading Oliver Twist -- I hope this will fill the void left by Little Dorrit. I didn't find the story quite as complex as his later works, but there's lots of great stuff in it, especially satire about the workhouse and the poor.
I've read this twice in the past couple of years so I don't know that I'll take the time for a reread, but I am definitely enjoying reading all the postings.
I'm glad you're enjoying it again. This is my first time reading it. I think I'm the only person on the planet that hasn't seen some sort of production based on Oliver Twist. I'm clueless as to the plot. After I finish the book I'll have to find a movie version.
Not knowing the plot, I'm interested to see how everything unfolds for Nancy. She seems to have a bit more to her than the other thieves.
Karenlibrarian - As much as I love OT, I cannot stop thinking about LT. And reading the two so close together, I do agree with what you said about it not being as complex. Dickens growth and maturity really show in LT. I was hoping you would join in but I completely understand you sitting it out:)
Kristi - As much as I love Oliver!, I wish I'd been able to read the book without having the movie experience first...you are lucky:) Yes, I think that is why I like Nancy, she actually struggles with right and wrong, unlike Fagin and Sykes.
I'm glad you're enjoying it! I'm really loving how simple the story is compared to some of the heavier books I've read.
I haven't seen Oliver! but I have played the soundtrack for it in orchestra. I'm debating whether I want to watch it after I finish. We'll see though. :)
I'm glad you're participating! Thank you!
Great post. I'm reading Oliver Twist for the first time, and I really like it. I think it's faster-paced than his other work.
Also, I love the humor in the book. It would be pretty depressing if Dickens didn't wrap everything up in sarcasm. :)
You make me want to pick up Oliver Twist - now! After Bleak House, my plan was to take a break from Dickens, but I may have to reconsider...
Love those character names, too... Mrs. Thingummy, Mr. Grimwig?! :-)
Allie - I am considering rewatching the musical as well after I am done reading OT. Although I watched it several times as a kid, I am realizing I have forgotten quite a bit of it. Thank you again for hosting:)
Darlyn - I agree...if there was no humorous or witty aspect to his writing, I don't think I could read him. I am glad you are having a good experience with this read:)
JoAnn - He has a real talent for coming up with these names. I saw a comment you left at Read the Book...I think the next Dickens you should pick up is Little Dorrit:)
The song from Oliver that sticks with me is, "Food, glorious, food!" :) I did a reread of this one last year and I think Dickens just gets better as I age. I'm about to read Hard Times for the first time, but you've got me wishing I had Little Dorrit on hand. Maybe that will be next. Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us!
Susan - Ooh, Hard Times is one I am looking forward to. Please come back and leave me a note telling me what you thought of it. I have only been reading Dickens for a couple of years but I agree with you...just the two years in between my readings of OT it seems like the book is even better...but I suppose it is me that has changed and not Dickens:) Anytime I get a chance, I will push Little Dorrit, so I hope she will make it on to your shelves soon. That song is one of the best and the way they filmed that scene was just genius.
This is only my second Dickens book. (I'm reading along with Allie et al.) I can't say I love it. :(
Jillian - Oh, I am sorry...did you like the first Dickens you read?
Post a Comment